Royals Look to Maximize Jonathan India and Michael Massey's Roles

With the arrival of Jonathan India to the Kansas City Royals, manager Matt Quatraro faces the challenge of fitting both India and Michael Massey into the lineup. Both players have predominantly played second base throughout their careers—India with the Reds and Massey with the Royals. However, with both now on the Royals' roster, creative solutions are being considered to ensure their bats remain in the lineup.


One possibility is platooning, with Massey batting left-handed and India batting right-handed. Another option involves rotating them in the designated hitter (DH) spot. Yet, an interesting third possibility suggested by Ken Rosenthal and Will Sammon of The Athletic is playing both in the outfield, specifically left field. 


India's Transition and Versatility:

India, who has exclusively played second base, prepared for a multi-positional role with the Reds in 2024 due to a potential infield logjam. Although he ended up playing mostly at second base, this preparation suggests he might adapt well to a new defensive role. 

Massey's Defensive Flexibility:

Massey has a bit more variety on his defensive resume, having played one game at third base and one inning in center field. Despite these experiences being limited, it indicates a willingness to try different positions.

Offensive Strength:

Despite their defensive uncertainties, both players were above-average hitters in 2024. India showcased excellent plate discipline with a 12.6% walk rate and a 108 wRC+, while Massey demonstrated strong contact skills and above-average power with a .190 ISO and a 102 wRC+. This offensive prowess is why the Royals are keen to keep both players in the lineup.

Lineup Strategy:

Rotating India and Massey in the DH spot could be one solution, but it's not ideal as the Royals likely want to keep the DH position available for Salvador Perez when Freddy Fermin is catching. Additionally, GM J.J. Picollo aims to maintain lineup flexibility while seeking further upgrades. Incorporating DH reps could facilitate acquiring a more impactful bat.

Future Acquisitions:

Anne Rogers of MLB.com reported that the Royals are searching for another hitter who can play both the infield and outfield. If India or Massey can adapt to this versatile role, Picollo might prioritize landing the best possible hitter rather than focusing solely on defensive flexibility. Given the Royals' offensive struggles, ranking 13th in runs scored, 14th in OPS, and 20th in wRC+ in 2024, any boost in their lineup is much needed.


As the Royals continue to strategize for the upcoming season, finding a balance in the lineup will be crucial for leveraging India's and Massey's strengths. Their ability to adapt and contribute, even outside their natural positions, will be key in the Royals' pursuit of success.